[分享] afterelton评选最佳50部同志电影出炉！！

kblovein

投票产生的大家可以去参考一下~
http://www.afterelton.com/movies/2008/9/50greatestgaymovies

第一名非常没悬念
1. Brokeback Mountain (2005)

Ferragamos or Birkenstocks? Mojitos or good ol’ beer? Gay men don’t seem to agree on much. But by a wide margin of nearly two-to-one, you chose Brokeback Mountain as the greatest gay movie of all time. And how could it be otherwise? “It’s not ‘gay,’” said some, trying to broaden the film’s appeal, “it’s a ‘universal love story’!”
But is it really? Plenty of heterosexuals have had the experience of hiding a love affair, but how many of them know what it’s like to be forced by society to deny themselves the very possibility of love? This is the daring and fundamentally “gay” question at the heart of Ang Lee’s 2005 masterpiece: can two men simply allow themselves to love each other? And though the movie is set in the past, it is, ultimately, the very choice that every gay man still must make.
Jake Gyllenhaal is flawless as Jack Twist in arguably the movie’s most difficult role. But Heath Ledger’s heartbreaking portrayal of Ennis Del Mar, a walking cautionary tale of homophobia’s logical end result, is a revelation — a total acting transformation made all the more tragic by Ledger’s death earlier this year. But the indignities and injustices that Jack and Ennis faced did not end at Brokeback Mountain’s closing credits. Upon the film’s release, the movie’s makers and fans were subjected to a six-month orgy of tasteless jokes from clueless comedians and bile-filed commentary from right-wing pundits. All of this negativity culminated when the movie, long considered the Oscar front-runner, lost Best Picture to a fine but unremarkable movie called Crash, perhaps the most egregious upset in Oscar history and almost certainly the result of lingering homophobia in Hollywood’s old guard.
But that fusillade of ridicule and outrage is already fading into the gloom of a bigoted past while the movie’s artistry and quiet power shines brighter than ever. Let’s face it: this isn’t just the greatest gay movie of all time, it’s one of the greatest movies ever.

[ 本帖最后由 kblovein 于 2008-9-8 13:13 编辑 ]

ljf7838

顶一个

allan830220

不觉得这部应该第一，喜欢小清新《shelter》

amaguy

断背上第一哦……
瞧人家这名字多好
山啊！实体啊！多衬托男人形象啊！
一直到现在都有这么句话嘛
人人心中都有座断背山……

jackie2x

19：50 我的现状

oleg

和所有评选一样，有实至名归；有仅仅是名气大，实则平平；个别牵强；个别令人费解，根本说不上同志电影，仅仅个别人物涉及到而已。

允诺幸福

差不多都是欧美的，为什么没有其他州的呀？前十部中的前七个我都看过，还蛮符合我的喜好的。

心型圈圈

觉得BBM拿第一名没悬念  感情用的很深刻   ~

ilovetdog

大部份也愛過，也認同這結果

rrrtutu

好多么看过。。。。拿着排名下片子学习去。
个人更偏好亚洲的同志片

莫失luvian

惭愧啊，好多没看过~~

wytgzs

有些垃圾片居然也有排名:s39

美好时光

看过一些，连另一部基片都在内啊，我觉得此片太美国派了，有点。。。也不觉得性爱巴士是gay片啊，算支线吧。总体来说此榜单还是包罗万象底

美好时光

背背山还真是吃香呢

嗜血天使

说实话，应该是我的问题，我没觉得断背山有那么的好，虽然是李安大人导演的~好吧，我承认是我的问题。50部。。我都完全不知道我都看了哪些？哈。。。

CYJRYO

其实，，
我想说。。
为什么是英文。。
我是英文小白。。。

ttkankan

《不良教育》和《神秘肌肤》讲的是两个主题啊，怎么类比啊？

candytotti

有几部我很喜欢的都排在好后{:3_264:}
没看过的还是满多的,还需再接再厉

zhangbz

好像那种温情片比较多

szzx777

但愿G片更丰富多彩！:s18

johnztper1

好的分享！  努力看~~

kkuger

迷情站台怎么不在呢，不过好多我喜欢的都不在

rudge

基本都看过了 没有我最喜欢的青春梦里人

hongtoo

我大概也看过5成。。不错

luomaren

说实话，如果说断背山 跟喜宴相比，我更加喜欢喜宴那样的故事，很有情感的那种，看断背山总是感觉缺少了点什么……